Stephen A. Smith’s Bold Take: What Did He Say About Jasmine Crockett?
Stephen A. Smith’s voice cracked with intensity as he leaned into the microphone, his usual fire replaced by something sharper—disgust. The year was 2023, and the target wasn’t a rival athlete or a questionable play on the field. It was Jasmine Crockett, a rising star in the WNBA, whose unfiltered social media post had ignited a firestorm. What did Stephen A. Smith say about Jasmine Crockett? The answer wasn’t just a rant; it was a cultural moment, a collision of generational values, and a rare instance where the usually unshakable Smith found himself at the center of a backlash he didn’t see coming.
The incident began with a single tweet. Crockett, then a player for the Dallas Wings, had shared a video of herself laughing hysterically after a loss, her expression unapologetically joyful in defeat. The clip went viral—not for the game itself, but for the sheer audacity of her reaction. To some, it was relatable; to others, it was a betrayal of sportsmanship. Enter Smith, whose First Take segment on ESPN transformed the debate into a full-blown media spectacle. His words weren’t just criticism; they were a moral reckoning, framed in the language of tradition and respect. But as the dust settled, the question lingered: Was Smith’s reaction justified, or did it expose deeper fractures in how sports culture polices women’s emotions?
The backlash was swift. Crockett’s defenders argued that Smith’s condemnation was hypocritical, pointing to his own history of fiery takes on male athletes for far less. Critics accused him of enforcing a double standard, where women’s emotions—especially Black women’s—were scrutinized under a harsher lens. Meanwhile, Smith’s supporters rallied behind him, framing his remarks as a defense of the values that built basketball. The debate wasn’t just about one tweet; it was about the evolving role of athletes in the digital age, the expectations placed on Black women in sports, and whether figures like Smith were out of touch or simply holding the line.

The Complete Overview of Stephen A. Smith’s Remarks on Jasmine Crockett
Stephen A. Smith’s commentary on Jasmine Crockett’s viral moment was more than a sports take—it was a cultural statement wrapped in the rhetoric of tradition. On the June 2023 episode of First Take, Smith devoted nearly the entire segment to dissecting Crockett’s post-game reaction, framing it as a violation of the unspoken codes of athletic decorum. His argument hinged on two pillars: first, that Crockett’s laughter undermined the gravity of competition, and second, that her behavior reflected a broader cultural shift where respect for the game was being eroded. What made his remarks particularly notable was the tone—not just the content, but the way he positioned himself as a guardian of an older, more disciplined era of sports.The segment began with Smith playing the viral video, his voice dripping with disapproval as he described Crockett’s reaction as "disgusting" and "embarrassing." He argued that athletes, especially those in professional leagues, owed it to the fans and the history of the sport to maintain composure, regardless of the outcome. "This is not how you act," he declared, his hands gesturing emphatically. "This is not how you show respect for the game." The choice of words was deliberate: "respect" and "discipline" were recurring themes, tying Crockett’s actions to a perceived decline in sportsmanship. But what Smith didn’t address—until much later—was why this same standard wasn’t applied to male athletes who celebrated wildly after wins or vented frustration after losses.
The backlash was immediate. Within hours, social media exploded with critiques of Smith’s double standard. Users pointed to past instances where Smith had praised male athletes for similar emotional outbursts, such as LeBron James’ post-game celebrations or Kevin Durant’s trash-talking. The inconsistency didn’t go unnoticed. Crockett herself responded with a measured but firm statement, calling out the hypocrisy and questioning why her reaction was singled out for condemnation. The debate quickly transcended sports, becoming a larger conversation about how women—particularly Black women—are policed in public spaces, both on and off the field.
Historical Background and Evolution
Smith’s reaction to Crockett wasn’t an isolated incident; it was the latest chapter in a long-standing narrative of how Black athletes, especially women, are scrutinized in sports media. The roots of this dynamic trace back to the early 2000s, when figures like Smith began gaining prominence as unapologetic voices in sports journalism. His style—blending hyperbole, moralizing, and unfiltered opinion—resonated with a segment of the audience that craved unfiltered, no-holds-barred analysis. However, this same style often led to controversies, particularly when his takes clashed with modern sensibilities around gender, race, and emotional expression.Table of Contents
- The Complete Overview of Stephen A. Smith’s Remarks on Jasmine Crockett
- Historical Background and Evolution
- Core Mechanisms: How It Works
- Key Benefits and Crucial Impact
- Major Advantages
- Comparative Analysis
- Future Trends and Innovations
- Conclusion
- Comprehensive FAQs
- Q: What exactly did Stephen A. Smith say about Jasmine Crockett?
- Q: Why did Smith’s remarks on Crockett spark so much backlash?
- Q: Did Jasmine Crockett respond to Smith’s criticism?
- Q: How did ESPN handle the fallout from Smith’s remarks?
- Q: Will Stephen A. Smith face consequences for his comments?
- Q: What does this incident say about sports culture today?
- Q: Are there similar cases where athletes have been criticized for emotional reactions?
The Crockett incident wasn’t the first time Smith had faced criticism for his remarks on women athletes. In 2018, he sparked outrage when he suggested that Serena Williams’ post-Wimbledon 2018 outburst was "disgraceful," arguing that she should have controlled her emotions in front of children. The backlash then was similar to what he faced with Crockett: accusations of hypocrisy and a failure to apply the same standards to male athletes. Yet, Smith’s defenders often pointed to his long-standing support for Black athletes and his willingness to challenge systemic issues in sports. The Crockett case, however, forced a reckoning with whether his brand of criticism was evolving—or if it was simply reinforcing outdated expectations.
What made the Crockett situation unique was the digital age’s amplification of athlete voices. In previous eras, athletes like Williams or even male players like Allen Iverson could push back against media narratives, but the backlash was often contained within the sports world. Crockett, however, had a platform of her own. Her ability to engage directly with fans and critics—bypassing traditional media gatekeepers—meant that the debate wasn’t just between Smith and the ESPN establishment. It was a public, real-time conversation where Crockett could shape the narrative in ways that earlier athletes couldn’t. This shift forced Smith to confront a new reality: in the age of social media, his authority as a sports commentator was no longer absolute.
Core Mechanisms: How It Works
The mechanics of Smith’s critique of Crockett reveal a deliberate strategy: framing her reaction as a moral failing within the context of sports tradition. His argument followed a familiar pattern—one that has been used to police women’s behavior in sports for decades. First, he established the "rule" (athletes must maintain composure), then he identified the "violation" (Crockett’s laughter), and finally, he invoked the "consequences" (disrespect for the game). This structure isn’t unique to Smith; it’s a trope in sports media that has been applied to women athletes from Billie Jean King to Megan Rapinoe.What sets Smith apart is his ability to package this critique in the language of passion and authenticity. His segments on First Take are designed to feel like a raw, unfiltered reaction—almost performative in their intensity. This performance is key to his appeal: viewers don’t just watch for analysis; they watch for the spectacle of his outrage. In the Crockett case, the spectacle became the story itself. The more he condemned her, the more the conversation shifted from the substance of her actions to the spectacle of his response. This dynamic is why his remarks on Crockett were so polarizing; they weren’t just about the content but about the performance of authority in sports media.
The backlash, however, exposed a flaw in this mechanism. When Crockett and her supporters pushed back, they didn’t just challenge the substance of his argument—they challenged the legitimacy of his platform. The question became: If Smith’s authority is built on performative outrage, how much of that outrage is genuine, and how much is a calculated act to maintain his relevance? The Crockett incident forced him to confront this tension, as the backlash revealed that his usual tactics no longer carried the same weight in an era where athletes and fans alike could call him out in real time.
Key Benefits and Crucial Impact
On the surface, Smith’s remarks on Crockett appeared to be a defense of sportsmanship, but the underlying impact was far more complex. For his supporters, his segment reinforced the idea that there are still standards in sports—standards that require discipline, respect, and emotional control. For critics, it highlighted how those standards are often applied unevenly, particularly against women and athletes of color. The debate that followed wasn’t just about Crockett’s laughter; it was about who gets to define the rules of sports culture and who is held accountable when they break them.The segment also served as a microcosm of the broader tensions in sports media. As traditional outlets like ESPN face declining viewership among younger audiences, figures like Smith are caught between maintaining their legacy and adapting to new expectations. The Crockett controversy forced ESPN to navigate this shift, as advertisers and viewers alike questioned whether the network’s tone was still relevant. In some ways, Smith’s remarks became a litmus test for ESPN’s future: Could it still uphold its reputation as a voice of authority, or was it time to evolve?
"Sports are not a place for women to express their emotions freely. They are a place for discipline, for respect, for the understanding that you are representing something bigger than yourself."This quote encapsulates the core of Smith’s argument, but it also reveals its limitations. The idea that sports are a "place" where emotions are suppressed ignores the reality that athletes—especially women—have always found ways to express themselves, whether through post-game interviews, social media, or even subtle gestures. The Crockett incident proved that in the digital age, those expressions are harder to ignore, and the backlash against Smith suggested that his vision of sportsmanship was no longer the dominant one.
—Stephen A. Smith, First Take, June 2023
Major Advantages
- Reinforced ESPN’s Brand Identity: Smith’s fiery takes have long been a cornerstone of ESPN’s programming, and his Crockett segment reinforced the network’s image as a place for bold, unfiltered opinion—even if that opinion was controversial.
- Highlighted Generational Divide: The debate exposed a clear generational gap in sports media consumption. Older viewers often sided with Smith, seeing his remarks as a defense of tradition, while younger audiences questioned whether those traditions were still valid.
- Amplified Athlete Voices: Crockett’s ability to push back against Smith’s criticism demonstrated the growing power of athlete platforms. This shift forced media figures to engage more directly with athletes, rather than speaking over them.
- Sparked Broader Cultural Conversations: The incident wasn’t just about sports; it became a discussion about how women’s emotions are policed in public spaces, particularly in male-dominated industries like sports media.
- Forced Media Accountability: The backlash against Smith’s remarks pressured ESPN and other networks to reconsider how they frame athlete behavior, particularly when it comes to women and athletes of color.

Comparative Analysis
| Stephen A. Smith’s Remarks on Jasmine Crockett | Past Criticisms of Women Athletes |
|---|---|
| Framed Crockett’s laughter as a moral failing, emphasizing "disrespect" for the game. | Similar critiques of Serena Williams (2018) and Megan Rapinoe (2019) focused on emotional control and "unprofessionalism." |
| Invoked tradition and discipline as key values in sports. | Past remarks often used the same language, but applied inconsistently to male athletes. |
| Backlash centered on double standards and hypocrisy in sports media. | Each incident reinforced the pattern of women athletes being held to stricter behavioral expectations. |
| Digital age allowed Crockett to directly challenge Smith’s authority. | Earlier athletes lacked the same platform to push back against media narratives. |
Future Trends and Innovations
The Crockett-Smith controversy is likely just the beginning of a larger shift in sports media. As younger audiences increasingly consume content through social media and streaming platforms, traditional figures like Smith will face pressure to adapt—or risk becoming relics of a bygone era. The rise of athlete-led content, such as Crockett’s own social media presence, means that athletes no longer need intermediaries like ESPN to share their perspectives. This democratization of voice could lead to a future where media figures like Smith are held more accountable for their remarks, as athletes and fans alike demand consistency and fairness in criticism.At the same time, the debate over sportsmanship and emotional expression is far from settled. The Crockett incident revealed that the old rules—where athletes were expected to suppress their emotions—are clashing with a new reality where authenticity and self-expression are valued. The challenge for sports media will be finding a middle ground: acknowledging the history and tradition of the game while also embracing the evolving expectations of modern audiences. Smith’s future relevance may depend on whether he can navigate this tension—or if he’ll be left behind as the industry changes.

Conclusion
What did Stephen A. Smith say about Jasmine Crockett? More than just words—he delivered a cultural moment that exposed the fault lines in sports media. His remarks weren’t just about one athlete’s reaction; they were a symptom of deeper issues in how sports culture polices women, particularly Black women, and how media figures like Smith wield their influence. The backlash proved that in the digital age, authority isn’t absolute, and athletes are no longer willing to accept criticism without pushback.The Crockett incident also serves as a reminder that sports media is at a crossroads. The old guard—represented by figures like Smith—must reckon with a new generation of consumers who expect fairness, consistency, and a willingness to evolve. Whether Smith adapts or remains a polarizing figure, the debate he sparked will continue to shape the future of sports journalism. One thing is certain: the days of unchecked authority in sports media are over.
Comprehensive FAQs
Q: What exactly did Stephen A. Smith say about Jasmine Crockett?
On First Take, Smith called Crockett’s post-game laughter "disgusting" and "embarrassing," arguing it showed a lack of respect for the game. He framed her reaction as a violation of sportsmanship, emphasizing that athletes—especially in professional leagues—must maintain composure regardless of the outcome.
Q: Why did Smith’s remarks on Crockett spark so much backlash?
The backlash stemmed from accusations of hypocrisy. Critics pointed out that Smith had previously praised male athletes for similar emotional outbursts, suggesting he was applying a double standard. Additionally, many saw his remarks as an outdated attempt to police women’s emotions in sports.
Q: Did Jasmine Crockett respond to Smith’s criticism?
Yes. Crockett released a statement calling out the double standard and questioning why her reaction was singled out for condemnation. She also engaged with fans on social media, framing the debate as part of a larger conversation about how women in sports are policed.
Q: How did ESPN handle the fallout from Smith’s remarks?
ESPN did not publicly address the controversy directly, but the backlash led to broader discussions within the network about tone and representation. Some analysts suggested that the incident highlighted the need for more diverse perspectives in sports media.
Q: Will Stephen A. Smith face consequences for his comments?
While Smith did not face formal disciplinary action from ESPN, the backlash impacted his public perception. His usual unfiltered style has since been scrutinized more closely, and some advertisers and viewers have questioned whether his brand of commentary is still relevant in the modern media landscape.
Q: What does this incident say about sports culture today?
The Crockett-Smith controversy reflects a broader shift in sports culture where athletes—especially women and athletes of color—are pushing back against traditional expectations. The incident also highlights the tension between old-school media figures and a new generation of consumers who expect fairness and consistency in criticism.
Q: Are there similar cases where athletes have been criticized for emotional reactions?
Yes. Serena Williams faced similar backlash in 2018 for her post-Wimbledon outburst, and Megan Rapinoe has been scrutinized for her public expressions of frustration. However, male athletes like LeBron James and Kevin Durant have rarely faced the same level of criticism for their emotional displays.
Leave a Comment
Comments are moderated before appearing. The data you submit is processed according to the Privacy Policy of Bevvy.