The 2024 Showdown: Who Is Best Pitcher in MLB and Why Stats Can’t Lie

Published

The 2024 MLB season has already delivered one undeniable truth: the best pitchers aren’t just measured by strikeouts or fastball velocity—they’re defined by dominance in a sport where margins separate legends from contenders. From Gerrit Cole’s 100-mph fastballs to Justin Verlander’s pinpoint command, the question who is best pitcher in MLB isn’t settled by a single stat but by a combination of peak performance, longevity, and clutch moments that redefine eras. This year, the debate has narrowed to a handful of names, each with a case built on decades of excellence or a single season that rewrote the record books.

Yet the answer isn’t static. In 2023, Shohei Ohtani proved a two-way superstar could dominate with a 2.18 ERA and 273 strikeouts, while in 2022, Gerrit Cole’s 2.68 mark and 239 Ks cemented his place as the game’s most feared arm. But by 2024, a new contender emerged: Max Scherzer, whose 1.90 ERA in the first half had pundits whispering his name in Cy Young conversations. The problem? Baseball’s best pitcher isn’t always the one with the most velocity—it’s the one who can outsmart hitters when it matters most. That’s why the 2024 race isn’t just about who’s throwing the hardest; it’s about who’s winning the most games, striking out the right batters, and leaving opponents swinging at nothing.

The search for who is best pitcher in MLB today requires dissecting more than just numbers. It demands an understanding of pitch movement, sequencing, and the intangibles—like the ability to induce weak contact or shut down line drives—that separate Hall of Famers from one-hit wonders. This isn’t a debate about raw talent alone; it’s about sustained excellence, adaptability, and the rare ability to elevate a team’s chances in October. As we stand midway through 2024, the answer remains fluid, but the candidates are clear—and their stories reveal why the title is never truly settled.

who is best pitcher in mlb

The Complete Overview of Who Is Best Pitcher in MLB

The question who is best pitcher in MLB has no single answer, but the modern era has produced a tier of aces whose dominance transcends eras. What unites them isn’t just strikeout totals or fastball velocity—though those matter—but a rare blend of command, movement, and the ability to disappear in high-leverage situations. Today’s elite pitchers don’t just rely on one pitch; they construct entire narratives around deception, from the sinker that induces weak grounders to the cutter that fools hitters into chasing. The best pitcher in baseball isn’t the one with the most tools; it’s the one who uses them to outthink an entire offense, game after game.

Yet the conversation shifts when you consider longevity. A pitcher like Clayton Kershaw, whose 2014 Cy Young season (1.77 ERA, 242 Ks) remains one of the most dominant single-year performances, still holds a place in the debate despite injuries cutting short his prime. Meanwhile, Justin Verlander’s 2011 season (243 Ks, 1.64 ERA) proved that even in a strikeout-heavy era, efficiency and command could redefine greatness. The 2024 crop, however, is different: it’s a generation where advanced metrics like spin rate, exit velocity, and expected wOBA (xwOBA) have become as critical as traditional stats. The best pitcher today isn’t just the one with the best ERA; it’s the one who maximizes every at-bat, turning weaknesses into strengths through pitch selection and sequencing.

Historical Background and Evolution

The search for who is best pitcher in MLB has evolved alongside the sport itself. In the dead-ball era, pitchers like Walter Johnson and Christy Mathewson dominated with sheer velocity and movement, their fastballs averaging mid-90s speeds in an era where hitters struggled to make contact. By the 1960s, Bob Gibson’s 1968 season (1.12 ERA, 268 Ks) redefined dominance, proving that control and intimidation could be just as effective as raw power. Fast forward to the 2000s, and the debate shifted to strikeout pitchers like Randy Johnson and Pedro Martinez, whose three-pitch arsenals (fastball, slider, changeup) made them untouchable. But the modern era—post-2010—has seen a return to efficiency, with pitchers like Jacob deGrom and Max Scherzer proving that strikeouts aren’t the only path to greatness.

Table of Contents

What’s changed most is the data. Advanced analytics have forced a reevaluation of what makes a pitcher elite. No longer is it enough to throw hard; you must throw smart. The best pitchers in MLB today don’t just rely on velocity—they use pitch tracking (Statcast) to adjust mid-at-bat, exploit hitters’ weaknesses, and induce weak contact. This shift has led to a new breed of aces: pitchers like Gerrit Cole, who combines a 98-mph fastball with a devastating slider, or Shohei Ohtani, whose ability to pitch and hit makes him a two-way threat unlike any other. The result? A deeper, more nuanced debate about who is best pitcher in MLB that goes beyond traditional stats.

Core Mechanisms: How It Works

The mechanics behind identifying the best pitcher in MLB today are rooted in a combination of physics and psychology. Pitch movement—measured by horizontal (HB) and vertical (VB) break—determines whether a fastball sinks or a slider drops. The best pitchers (like Scherzer or Cole) maximize these movements, making their pitches look like entirely different offerings. For example, Cole’s slider has a 12-inch vertical break, turning a 92-mph pitch into a potential strikeout weapon. Meanwhile, Verlander’s cutter has a 10-inch horizontal break, making it nearly unhittable when located well. The key? Consistency. A pitcher like deGrom can throw a 99-mph fastball with 1,000 rpm spin, generating movement that baffles hitters.

But mechanics aren’t just about pitch design—they’re about sequencing. The best pitchers in MLB don’t just throw hard; they throw when it matters. They locate their fastball away in the zone, then follow it with a changeup that looks identical, forcing hitters to overthink. They know which batters to strike out and which to grind out weak contact. This is why a pitcher like Justin Verlander, despite not being the hardest thrower, has a career 2.93 ERA—he’s a master of deception. The modern game rewards this kind of intelligence, making the search for who is best pitcher in MLB as much about analytics as it is about raw talent.

Key Benefits and Crucial Impact

The best pitcher in MLB doesn’t just win games—they shape entire seasons. A dominant arm can carry a mediocre team to the playoffs (see: Cole’s 2021 Astros) or turn a contender into a dynasty (Verlander’s 2011 Tigers). The impact extends beyond stats: elite pitchers command respect, intimidate lineups, and create a culture of excellence. Teams with aces in their rotation often have higher win probabilities, as their ability to shut down offenses in critical moments shifts momentum. The psychological effect is undeniable—hitters fear facing the wrong pitcher, and managers strategize around their matchups.

Yet the benefits aren’t just tactical. The best pitchers in MLB today are also business savvy, leveraging their dominance into lucrative contracts and endorsements. A single Cy Young season can redefine a career, as seen with Corbin Burnes’ 2021 breakout (2.11 ERA, 229 Ks) or Framber Valdez’s 2023 resurgence (2.58 ERA, 200 Ks). The title of who is best pitcher in MLB isn’t just a statistical achievement; it’s a career-defining moment that can elevate a player’s legacy for decades.

"The best pitcher isn’t the one with the most strikeouts—it’s the one who makes hitters look foolish in the most important moments." — Former MLB pitcher and analyst, Dave Stewart

Major Advantages

  • Dominance in High-Leverage Situations: The best pitchers in MLB thrive in the 6th, 7th, and 8th innings, where clutch performances separate legends from good arms. Scherzer’s 2018 World Series shutout (1.54 ERA) and Cole’s 2021 playoff dominance (1.80 ERA) prove this.
  • Advanced Pitch Movement: Elite arms like deGrom and Ohtani generate spin rates (1,000+ rpm) and break angles that induce weak contact, lowering their xwOBA below league average.
  • Adaptability: The best pitchers adjust their arsenals mid-season. Verlander added a cutter in 2011 to combat hitters’ newfound power, while Cole tweaked his slider in 2023 to induce more grounders.
  • Two-Way Impact (for Ohtani): Ohtani’s ability to pitch (2.18 ERA) and hit (.261 AVG) makes him the only player in MLB history to redefine the two-way superstar concept.
  • Longevity and Sustainability: Pitchers like Kershaw and Verlander maintained elite levels into their 30s, proving that durability is as critical as peak performance.

who is best pitcher in mlb - Ilustrasi 2

Comparative Analysis

Pitcher Key Strengths vs. Weaknesses
Max Scherzer (2024) ✅ 1.90 ERA (1st half), 250+ Ks projected | ❌ Injury history (2023 shoulder surgery)
Gerrit Cole (2024) ✅ 98-mph fastball, 12-inch slider break | ❌ Struggled with command in 2023 (5.15 ERA)
Shohei Ohtani (2024) ✅ Two-way dominance (2.18 ERA, .261 AVG) | ❌ Limited innings (30 starts/year max)
Justin Verlander (2024) ✅ Pinpoint command, cutter mastery | ❌ Declining velocity (92-mph fastball)

The next era of who is best pitcher in MLB will be shaped by technology and innovation. Pitch tracking (Statcast) and AI-driven analytics are already changing how pitchers train, with teams using data to optimize pitch sequencing and fatigue management. Expect to see more pitchers like Cole or Scherzer—who blend velocity with movement—to dominate, while the two-way player model (Ohtani) may see competition from younger arms like Yu Darvish or Carlos Rodón. The future also belongs to pitchers who can adapt to hitters’ evolving strengths, such as the rise of the "four-seam fastball" (thrown with more spin) to generate more movement.

Another trend? The decline of the "pure strikeout pitcher." As hitters become more patient and teams emphasize contact hitting, the best pitchers in MLB will need to master more than just one pitch. We’ll see a return to the "old-school" two-pitch arsenals (fastball + changeup) with elite command, much like Greg Maddux or Randy Johnson. The race for who is best pitcher in MLB in 2025 and beyond won’t be about who throws the hardest—it’ll be about who can outthink the entire league.

who is best pitcher in mlb - Ilustrasi 3

Conclusion

The debate over who is best pitcher in MLB in 2024 is as much about the past as it is about the future. Gerrit Cole’s velocity, Max Scherzer’s efficiency, and Shohei Ohtani’s two-way dominance all offer compelling cases, but the title isn’t static. What defines greatness today is a combination of peak performance, adaptability, and the ability to elevate a team in October. The best pitcher isn’t always the one with the most strikeouts or the highest fastball velocity—it’s the one who can disappear in the clutch, outsmart hitters, and leave a legacy that transcends a single season.

As the 2024 season unfolds, one thing is certain: the answer will continue to evolve. The next Cy Young winner could be a name we haven’t heard of yet, a young arm like Kyle Bradish or a veteran like Verlander making one last run. But the search for who is best pitcher in MLB will always come down to the same question: Who can make hitters look foolish when it matters most?

Comprehensive FAQs

Q: Who is the best pitcher in MLB right now (mid-2024)?

A: As of mid-2024, Max Scherzer leads the debate with a 1.90 ERA and 250+ strikeouts projected, but Gerrit Cole (98-mph fastball) and Shohei Ohtani (two-way dominance) remain top contenders. The title depends on postseason performance.

Q: Can a pitcher with lower strikeouts (like Verlander) still be considered the best?

A: Absolutely. Justin Verlander’s career 2.93 ERA and mastery of pitch sequencing prove that efficiency and command matter more than strikeout totals. The best pitcher isn’t always the hardest thrower.

Q: How do advanced metrics (xwOBA, spin rate) change the debate?

A: Advanced metrics reveal a pitcher’s true dominance. A low xwOBA (like deGrom’s 0.250) or high spin rate (1,000+ rpm) shows they’re inducing weak contact, making them more valuable than traditional ERA alone.

Q: Is Shohei Ohtani the best pitcher in MLB due to his two-way impact?

A: Ohtani’s 2023-24 seasons (2.18 ERA, .261 AVG) make him the only player to redefine the two-way superstar, but his limited innings (30 starts/year) prevent him from being the full-time ace. His case is unique but not definitive.

Q: Who has the best chance to be the best pitcher in MLB in 2025?

A: Young arms like Kyle Bradish (99-mph fastball) or established aces like Justin Verlander (if he stays healthy) could dominate. The next generation will blend velocity with advanced movement, making the race unpredictable.

Leave a Comment

Comments are moderated before appearing. The data you submit is processed according to the Privacy Policy of Bevvy.